NFL Week 5 Betting Recap: Point Spread, Over/Under Results & Analysis (2020)

Week 5 Betting Recap and Dak Prescott Injury

Dak Prescott is done for the year. How will the Cowboys respond? (Photo by Andrew Dieb/Icon Sportswire)

It was an eventful NFL Week 5 to be sure:

  • The Super Bowl champs lost for the first time since last November.
  • The San Francisco 49ers got crushed by Miami at home while Jimmy Garoppolo got benched.
  • We got another big comeback on Monday Night Football to cap off the week.
  • Dallas QB Dak Prescott suffered a gruesome injury to his lower leg and is done for the year.

Meanwhile, the week is not officially over, as Buffalo and Tennessee still play a rare Tuesday night game. (We will update the numbers in this post on Wednesday after the game).

In this post, we’ll examine not only how teams performed against the point spread and over/under lines in Week 5, but also review some of the fluky, improbable outcomes that can make ATS records misleading.

This level of analysis often provides clues as to which teams may be setting up well to cover the spread in the future.

(To search for your own NFL betting trends, we invite you to use the beta version of our BetIQ Trend Finder Tool.)

Free 3-Day Premium Trial

Free 3-Day Premium Trial

Survivor Pools - Pick’em Pools - Betting

Get Picks Now

NFL Week 5 By the Betting Numbers

  • Biggest upset: Las Vegas over Kansas City (+11, +361 money line)
  • Biggest ATS cover margin: Miami over San Francisco (+34.5, won by 26 points as 8.5-point underdog)
  • Most points above over/under line: Philadelphia-Pittsburgh (+23, 67 total points vs. O/U line of 44.0)
  • Most points below over/under line: Baltimore-Cincinnati (-19, 30 total points vs. O/U line of 49.0)
  • Most points scored vs. team expectation: Miami (43 points vs. 21.0 expected)
  • Fewest points scored vs. team expectation: Cincinnati (3 points vs. 18.25 expected)

Dak Prescott’s Injury and Its Impact on Dallas

Dak Prescott suffered a horrific ankle injury on Sunday, and will be out for the rest of the 2020 season. Through four weeks, Prescott had thrown for more passing yards than any other QB in NFL history. Now, the Cowboys will turn to veteran Andy Dalton at the quarterback position.

How should you value this QB change and how it could impact the Cowboys? You may have seen some people noting that the early look-ahead line for the Week 6 Dallas-Arizona game was Dallas by 3. Now, the line has opened with the Cardinals instead favored by 3. That might lead you to think that Prescott is “worth” 6 points more than Dalton.

But not so fast. Remember that the look-ahead line was also posted before both teams played on Sunday. With Arizona rebounding to beat the Jets by 20 (more than expected), while Dallas barely survived a tight game against the winless Giants, the power ratings for both teams changed as a result. In the end, about 1.6 points of that difference can be attributed to the impact of Week 5 results.

That would imply that the betting market is initially valuing the Prescott loss as being worth closer to 4.4 points.

We’ve seen quite a range in outcomes when franchise quarterbacks have been lost for the season recently. The Lions cratered in 2019 after Matthew Stafford suffered a season-ending back injury, while the Saints went undefeated when Teddy Bridgewater had to play in place of Drew Brees. So both the quality of the backup and the nature of the offense can impact it.

Dalton, while maybe not as good as he was five years ago, is 33 years old and only one year removed from starting for Cincinnati. Dallas also has plenty of offensive weapons at wide receiver, and there are other factors (as we noted last week about Dallas’ fumbles) that suggest there may be some non-QB related reasons to think Dallas is due for some positive regression against the spread.

Fourth Down Calls and Point Spread Covers

Some fourth down outcomes led to big swings in Week 5 results, including upsets as well as some favorites holding on to win:

Philadelphia-Pittsburgh

Facing a 4th and 5 at the Pittsburgh 39 and down by 2 points, Eagles head coach Doug Pederson opted for a 57-yard field goal attempt with just over 3 minutes left. It failed, and after taking over near midfield, Pittsburgh scored the sealing touchdown to secure both the win and the cover (Pittsburgh -7). That field goal attempt looks like poor strategy for a number of reasons.

First, the chance of success for a field goal of that length were no better than the chance of converting the fourth down. In 2019, teams converted 7 of 18 field goals of 56 to 58 yards (41%) versus converting 14 of 27 (52%) of 4th-and-5 attempts.

Second, a made field goal to take a one-point lead would have left Pittsburgh with plenty of time and just needing a field goal to win. A fourth down conversion, on the other hand, would have allowed Philadelphia to continue possession and either score a touchdown or kick a shorter field goal, and leave Pittsburgh less time for its last possession in either case.

Kansas City-Las Vegas

The Raiders made two key 4th-and-1 calls in their upset of Kansas City. Tied at 24-24 and in field goal range, Derek Carr converted to set up the go-ahead touchdown. Then, just inside the two-minute warning, Carr again converted to seal the victory, rather than punt it back to KC up by 8.

Meanwhile, Patrick Mahomes threw his one interception on 4th-and-7, with the Chiefs down by 9. It was returned near the goal line and set up a touchdown to put the Raiders up by 16 late in the fourth quarter.

Seattle-Minnesota

Finally, fourth down plays were a massive factor in Seattle surviving against Minnesota to stay undefeated.

With two minutes left, at the Seattle 6, Minnesota went for a 4th-and-1 when up by 5 points to try to seal the victory, rather than go up by 8 points. They were stuffed.

Then, on the ensuing drive, Russell Wilson hit D.K. Metcalf for a big 39-yard gain on 4th-and-10, before throwing the game-winning touchdown on 4th-and-6 with just 20 seconds remaining.

NFL Home Field Advantage in 2020

One of the things we are tracking this year is how home teams are performing, with many teams playing in front of no fans to start the year. In Week 5, home teams went 9-5 straight up and 6-8 ATS.

Weekly NFL Home Team Records, 2020 Season To Date

WeekWLTWIN PCTATS WATS LATS TATS PCT
188050.0%97056.3%
2115068.8%88050.0%
369140.6%79043.7%
469030.8%510023.1%
595061.5%68038.5%
Overall4036152.6%3542045.5%

However, last year, home teams were only 43.5% SU and 37.0% ATS in the first five weeks of the season, performing even worse than this year.

Over the previous five seasons (2015-2019), home teams have won 53.5% SU and 46.6% ATS in the first five weeks. So home teams having a sub-50% ATS record so far in 2020 doesn’t buck any recent historical trend.

2020 Point Spread Result Splits

Here’s how some of the more standard spilts look after Week 5:

TYPEATS WATS LATS TATS %
Favorites3740048.1%
Underdogs4037051.9%
Home Teams3542045.5%
Away Teams4235054.5%

2020 Scoring vs. Historical Seasons

Scoring finally slowed a bit in Week 5 after a steady climb in recent weeks, and Unders hit in 7 of 14 games. Overs are now 43-33-1 on the season (56.5%). In the previous five years, overs hit at a 50.9% rate over the first five weeks.

Here’s a running tally of how overall NFL scoring so far in 2020 compares to the full season averages of recent seasons, based on average total points scored per game:

20202019201820172016
50.845.646.743.445.6

Turnovers, Miscues & Failures: Week 5 Edition

In this section each week, we list a summary of drives that ended with turnovers, but not only official turnovers like interceptions and fumbles.

We also tally up other high-leverage events that likely led to either loss of points or great field position for an opponent. Safeties and blocked punts are included in turnovers, and blocked field goals are included in missed field goal attempts.

Week 5 Team ATS Records Based On Turnovers, Missed Field Goals, and Failed 4th Down Attempts

TeamTurnoversFG MissDownsTOTALATS Result
Jacksonville2215Lost
San Francisco3025Lost
Cincinnati3014Lost
Baltimore1113Won
Indianapolis3003Lost
Buffalo3003Lost
Minnesota2013Won
Philadelphia2103Lost
Cleveland2002Won
Dallas2002Lost
Houston2002Won
LA Chargers0112Won
LA Rams1012Won
NY Jets0022Lost
Tampa Bay1012Lost
Arizona1001Won
Atlanta1001Lost
Chicago1001Won
Kansas City1001Lost
Las Vegas1001Won
New Orleans1001Lost
NY Giants1001Won
Pittsburgh1001Won
Seattle1001Lost
Washington0011Lost
Carolina0000Won
Miami0000Won
Tennessee0000Won

Teams with 4 or more turnovers, missed field goals or failed attempts went 0-3 ATS.

Teams that had zero drives end in those events went 3-0 ATS, with all three winning outright as underdogs.

Drive-Ending Miscues By Team: 2020 Season Tally

Here’s a summary of the full season so far showing the net number of drives ending in turnovers or miscues for each team.

As you might expect, most of the teams at the top have winning records against the spread, while the teams at the bottom have losing records ATS.

2020 Season Summary, Drives Ending in Turnovers or Other Failed Plays

TeamMistakesOpponentNetATS Record
Baltimore820123-2
Seattle516114-1
Miami61593-2
Tennessee41171-3
Pittsburgh41173-1
Green Bay3964-0
Kansas City61263-2
Tampa Bay91452-3
LA Rams91233-2
Cincinnati91233-2
New Orleans4732-3
Buffalo101003-2
Atlanta101001-4
Chicago101003-2
New England109-12-2
Washington1211-11-3
Arizona98-13-2
Cleveland109-13-2
Houston86-21-4
Indianapolis107-33-2
NY Jets1310-30-5
LA Chargers106-44-1
San Francisco1410-42-3
Detroit62-41-3
Carolina84-43-2
Las Vegas83-53-2
NY Giants127-53-2
Jacksonville148-62-3
Denver148-63-1
Minnesota114-73-2
Philadelphia147-71-4
Dallas143-110-5

2020 NFL ATS & Over/Under Performance By Team

Finally, here are updated against the point spread and over/under records so far in 2020. You can check out more trends on our BetIQ NFL betting trends page.

2020 NFL ATS and O/U Records

TeamWLTStreak ATSOverUnderPushO/U Streak
Arizona320W1050U5
Atlanta140L3320U2
Baltimore320W1140U1
Buffalo310W2301T1
Carolina320W3230U3
Chicago320W1230U2
Cincinnati320L1230U1
Cleveland320W3410O4
Dallas050L5410O4
Denver310W1220O1
Detroit130L1310O1
Green Bay400W4310U1
Houston140W1320U1
Indianapolis320L1230O1
Jacksonville230L3320U1
Kansas City320L1230O1
LA Chargers410W2230O2
LA Rams320W1230U2
Las Vegas320W1401O1
Miami320W1230O1
Minnesota320W3320U1
New England220L1220U1
New Orleans230L1500O5
NY Giants320W2230O1
NY Jets050L5320U1
Philadelphia140L1320O1
Pittsburgh310W2310O3
San Francisco230L2320O1
Seattle410L1410O1
Tampa Bay230L2320U1
Tennessee030L3210O2
Washington230L1320U1
Free 3-Day Premium Trial

Free 3-Day Premium Trial

Survivor Pools - Pick’em Pools - Betting

Get Picks Now